Would You Rather Opinion Writing Prompts for 2nd & 3rd Grade | Persuasive Writing Activities
Teaching opinion writing in 2nd and 3rd grade doesn’t have to be a struggle! With the right opinion writing prompts – especially fun, engaging ones like “Would You Rather” – you can introduce the foundations of persuasive writing in a way that feels like play but builds real writing skills. Whether you’re looking for digital opinion writing activities or printable persuasive writing worksheets, this resource is a game-changer.
Whether you’re teaching in person, online, or using a blended learning model, these digital and printable opinion writing activities are an easy way to boost engagement and build foundational persuasive writing skills. No prep. No stress. And lots of smiles.
Why Would You Rather Writing Prompts Work for Teaching Opinion Writing
Kids love making choices – and even more than that, they love defending those choices. Whether it’s choosing between a castle or a house, a cat or a dog, or reading vs. painting, students naturally want to explain their thinking.
That’s exactly why Would You Rather prompts make such a powerful tool for introducing persuasive writing as they:
Encourage critical thinking
Help students learn to state an opinion
Reinforce giving reasons to support that opinion
Provide daily writing practice in a familiar format
It’s the perfect stepping stone to more structured persuasive writing.
Would You Rather Opinion Writing Prompts for 2nd & 3rd Grade | Persuasive Writing Activities
What’s Included in These 2nd & 3rd Grade Opinion Writing Worksheets?
This Would You Rather Opinion Writing Pack includes 60 printable and digital writing prompts designed for second and third grade students.
Each slide or worksheet features:
A Would You Rather…? writing prompt (e.g., Would you rather be a bird or a mouse?)
A graphic organizer to help students plan and organize their opinion
A self-editing checklist for independent revision
Optional extra-lined writing paper for younger students or developing writers
Digital Format:
Google Slides
Students can type directly into text boxes
Perfect for Google Classroom or virtual learning
Printable Format:
Delete the text boxes and print
Easy to use in writing centers, ELA rotations or sub plans
- No prep required – just print and go!
10 Classroom Ideas for Using These Opinion Writing Prompts
This flexible resource fits seamlessly into your daily routine. Here are ten ways real teachers are using these prompts:
✅ Mini-Lessons on Persuasive Writing
Use one slide to model how to form an opinion, brainstorm reasons, and write a clear paragraph.
✅ Morning Work or Bell Ringers
Start the day with a quick, meaningful writing task that students enjoy.
✅ ELA Writing Centers
Add a few printed prompts to your writing station for independent writing practice.
✅ Digital Writing Assignments
Assign Google Slides – students type directly into the slides and submit digitally.
✅ Substitute Teacher Plans
Leave a no-prep writing packet for your sub. Instructions are clear, and students stay engaged.
✅ Early Finisher Activities
No more “I’m done!” interruptions—just point students to the next Would You Rather prompt.
✅ Partner or Small Group Debates
Have students discuss their opinions with a partner, then write independently using the graphic organizer.
✅ Writing Journals
Collect completed prompts in a persuasive writing journal throughout the school year.
✅ Self-Editing
Use the built-in checklist to reinforce editing and revising—students take ownership of improving their work.
✅ Differentiation for All Learners
Support struggling writers with extra-lined pages, or challenge advanced students to write multiple paragraphs.
Would You Rather Opinion Writing Prompts for 2nd & 3rd Grade | Persuasive Writing Activities
Some of the included prompts:
Would you rather be a tiger or an elephant?
Would you rather choose science or social studies?
Would you rather be a firefighter or a teacher?
Would you rather write or sing?
Would you rather ride in a carriage or a car?
Each one sparks creativity and gives students something to say. They’re also easy to tie into seasonal themes, holidays, or cross-curricular topics.
Why This Resource Works
This isn’t just another stack of worksheets. It’s a versatile, standards-aligned writing tool that teachers come back to again and again, because it works.
✅ Easy to implement
✅ Engaging for students
✅ Supports persuasive writing standards
✅ Great for both whole group and independent practice
✅ Adaptable to paper or digital use
Plus, the self-editing checklist helps students develop real revision skills – something that’s often overlooked in early writing instruction.
Common Core Standards Aligned:
Join my Free Resource Library to receive exclusive FREE content:
Click here to check out our narrative writing prompts for 2nd grade
Let’s connect!
opinion writing prompts for 2nd grade
opinion writing prompts for 3rd grade
would you rather writing prompts
persuasive writing activities for 2nd and 3rd grade
teaching opinion writing
persuasive writing prompts for elementary
teaching persuasive writing
printable opinion writing worksheets
digital writing activities for students
persuasive writing graphic organizer
writing center activities for 2nd grade
early finisher writing activity
ELA opinion writing for 3rd grade
fun writing prompts for kids
No Comments